Should Disgust Influence Our Considered Moral Judgments

This paper will examine the normative question â€Å"should disgust influence our considered moral judgments?† Daniel Kelly addresses in chapter five of his book, Yuck!, in two profoundly opposite views. These two views are between the moral disgust advocate who say, â€Å"yes† to the question and the moral disgust skeptics who say â€Å"no†. We will discuss these two very different views in depth, what Kelly’s views are, his account of the nature of disgust, and lastly, how he uses the Entanglement thesis and Co-opt thesis view to debunk the moral disgust advocates view on disgust. Before this paper can examine moral disgust in depth we must first define core disgust and how core disgust transformed into moral disgust. Core disgust is an emotional response of revulsion at the prospect of something that is considered to be offensive, distasteful or unpleasant. This emotional response was created to protect our bodies from harm and originally was developed to serve as an oral defense, a function to protect people from poisonous plants and disease avoidance. However core disgust has evolved along side with civilization and has now grown into elaborated disgust. Disgust is now not just protecting us from food, animals, or body products it has now evolved to include poor hygiene, sexual violations, body envelope violations, and any contact with death or dead bodies. Additional triggers of disgust are interpersonal contamination and socio-moral disgust, which is defined as disgust aroundShow MoreRelatedDifferences In Emotions876 Words   |  4 Pagespresent research aimed to examine whether individual differences in emotion can predict the judgment made in moral reactions. To be specific, as the representative trait emotions, trait disgust and trait anger were investigated, and the study also analyzed their relationship with two moral domains, harm and authority. It was expected that trait disgust would be positively associated with the moral judgment of harm, and authority values, and trait anger would also positively associate with those twoRead MoreReason And Disgust : Moral Foundations And Utilitarian Judgments3323 Words   |  14 Pages Reason and Disgust in Moral Foundations and Utilitarian Judgments Gajan Thiyagarajah (636280) PSYC20009 - Personality and Social Psychology - 2014Abstract The current study considered the recent debate in moral psychology as to the primacy of emotion in individual moral foundations and judgments (Haidt, 2001) against previous conceptions of consciously driven reasoning processes as the major determinant in moral decisions (Turiel, 1983). The study, involving 596 undergraduate psychology studentsRead MoreEthical Issues on the Treatment of Animals Essay722 Words   |  3 Pagespeople look upon these roles with favoritism, some with disgust. Animals are considered different from humans by some people because of their behavior, mannerisms or actions. Some animals are used as food by humans and other animals, while others are trapped for their furs. Many times people acquire animals for pets, only to neglect or mistreat them. For many years, the ethical treatment of animals has been a very controversial topic for moral discussion, often in reference to an ethical code or ruleRead MoreIs Neo Sentimentalism Morally Moral? Essay1914 Words   |  8 Pagesand sufficient for moral judgements. According to sentimentalist theories, moral judgements are expressions of sentiments – dispositions to have certain emotions. Neo-sentimentalism is an improved theory that brought reasoning into attention. Neo-sentimentalists claim that to judge if something is right or wrong is to judge whether it is appropriate to feel a certain moral emotion towards it. In the presented essay, I argue that both emotions and reasoning might influence moral judgements. It mightRead More Dogmatism Character of Religion Essay1417 Words   |  6 Pagesâ€Å"Plato’s Dream† is a short story written in 1756 by the French philosopher and satirist Franà §ois-Marie Arouet who published under the name of Voltaire. This text is considered as one of the first work of the genre of science fiction. In this story, Voltaire explained the doctrine taught by Plato to his disciples. It is about Demiurgos, the creator of the infinite space, who wanted to test the geniuses of his supreme creatures. He gave each one a small piece of material to settle. Demogorgon, oneRead MoreThe Rationality And Moral Significance Of Emotions1629 Words   |  7 Pagesrecognise emotions in others. It is remarkable how often we are wrong about our own emotions and misread the emotions of others. Philosophers often call emotions appropriate or inappropriate. Virtue ethicis ts put a lot of importance to emotions and claim that emotions are an essential motivator of ethical behaviour and we should ethically assess people’s emotions responses directly (de Sousa 2014). The rationality and moral significance of emotions remains debatable due to the ambiguous questions aboutRead MoreThe Rationality And Moral Significance Of Emotions1717 Words   |  7 Pagesrecognise emotions in others. It is remarkable how often we are wrong about our own emotions and misread the emotions of others. Philosophers often call emotions appropriate or inappropriate. Virtue ethicists put a lot of importance to emotions and claim that emotions are an essential motivator of ethical behaviour and we should ethically assess people’s emotions responses directly (de Sousa 2014). The rationality and moral significance of emotions remains debatable due to the ambiguous questions aboutRead More The Light and Dark Forces in Joseph Conrads Heart of Darkness1667 Words   |  7 PagesKurtzs story. We slowly get to know more and more about Kurtz. Part of the meaning of Heart of Darkness is that we learn about reality through other peoples accounts of it, many of which are, themselves, twice-told tales. Marlow is the source of our story, but he is also a character within the story we read. Marlow has always followed the sea, as the novel puts it. His voyage up the Congo river, however, is his first experience in freshwater travel. Conrad uses Marlow as a narrator in order toRead MoreCultural Psychology and Cross-Cultural Psychology3267 Words   |  13 Pagesprospect of psychology that integrates many cultural studies. Cross-cultural psychology would not exist without the focused studies of cultural psychology. Cultural psychology focuses on the interaction of behavior and the specific environmental influence whereas cross-cultural psychology focuses on the psychological diversity among varying cultures. Each field of psychology uses a different approach in regard to understanding and explaining the relationship between culture and psychological phenomenaRead MoreA Brief Note On Gay Marriage And Same Sex Marriage2156 Words   |  9 Pagessomeone is a homosexual or heterosexual is if the person voluntarily tells their sexual preference. Homosexuals are normal humans that should not be judged off their sexual preference. I personally know a few gay men and women that do not act like a homosexual or claim to be a homosexual. The reason they said they isolate their true feelings is because other morals and values. Homosexuals do not only date, but the desire to marry their significant other is becoming common. â€Å"Every since Massachusetts